When Value Engineering Fails, Unnecessarily (VSD Control)

Written By Bryce Anderson

Sometimes value engineering fails, not because the concept does not work, but because we stop short of providing a complete solution.

Featured - Latest published online course

BMS for mechanical consultants course

This course was developed by a BMS consultant for mechanical consultants involved in Building Management System projects. Learn how to reduce risk to your company, your client, and the BMS contractor.

  • Self-paced online course.

  • 12 hours of video lessons.

  • Training manual (+90 pages).

  • BMS design examples.

  • A sample of Lifecycle Controls BMS specification clauses are provided to assist with learning. You can use these in your own specification.

Online shop

Featured - BMS online shop
BMS Annual maintenance fee proposal (for BMS/BAS companies)
BMS Annual maintenance fee proposal (for BMS/BAS companies)
$500.00

AU$ Australian dollar

The annual Building Management System (BMS) maintenance proposal is the first step in transitioning from a typically preventative maintenance strategy into a modern BMS strategy.

Chiller Management System visualisation and analysis manual
Chiller Management System visualisation and analysis manual
$99.00

AU$ Australian dollar

The Chiller Management System (CMS) visualisation and analysis manual was developed to provide a resource for engineers who want to provide best-in-class chiller management system visualisation and analysis.

BMS Specification (for consultants)
BMS Specification (for consultants)
$2,500.00

AU$ Australian dollar

This is the same Building Management System (BMS) specification that Lifecycle Controls uses for BMS upgrades and new construction projects. It has been updated and modified over the years from lessons learnt on real-life projects.

Free control strategy mini courses

Create a free account in our Learning Management System and complete the free chilled water control system mini-course. A certificate is provided at the end of the course. A copy of the control strategy is provided as a Microsoft Word document for you to modify in your own BMS designs.

Please join our newsletter

  • To be notified when new courses, design templates, and digital products are published.

  • For updates to coaching availability.

  • For updates to business-to-business consulting services.

  • New Youtube video releases and occasional updates on what I am up to.

  • I will not fill up your inbox with crap.

Bryce Anderson

Bryce Anderson

I am an independent Building Management System consultant based in Australia. I started in the BMS industry in 1998 and initially worked for BMS companies for the first 15 years of my career (2 years in South Africa, 9 years in London, and 4 years in Melbourne). In 2014 I transitioned into BMS consulting, saw a massive gap in the lack of specialist BMS consulting, and started Lifecycle Controls in 2017.

My focus is currently on BMS technical training, coaching, and B2B consulting for BMS companies and mechanical consultancies. Because, fixing one project at a time was making no difference. Training thousands of engineers will :-)

More Building Management System videos
FIVE reasons building owners do not approve important fee proposals
FIVE reasons building owners do not approve important fee proposals

Understand why your customers do not approve important fee proposals and build a pipeline of service project work.

Where will the BMS be in 10 years?
Where will the BMS be in 10 years?

Where does the BMS/BAS fit in a world of technology? Where will the BMS/BAS be in 10 years?

BMS/BAS Distributed power and controls
BMS/BAS Distributed power and controls

We are building buildings faster than ever before, but we haven’t changed how we design and install the BMS/BAS. To keep up we need to completely change how we design and install BMS/BAS systems.

Who owns the cloud data - not who you think
Who owns the cloud data - not who you think

Some technology companies will market their product as opening up the lock-in from the BMS and the BMS contractor. That may not be quite right.

How we resource BMS projects in the future might change (should change)
How we resource BMS projects in the future might change (should change)

People don’t want to work like they have been for the past 100 years. People want more than just work-life balance. They want the flexibility to work where they want and when they want.

Who is responsible for your professional development?
Who is responsible for your professional development?

Who is responsible for your continuous professional development? Your employer? You? Watch this video to find out.

Chiller Management System visualisation and analysis
Chiller Management System visualisation and analysis

The Chiller Management System (CMS) visualisation and analysis manual provides a resource for engineers that want to provide best-in-class chiller management system visualisation and analysis.

Do you think you know OA control? Separate min OA volume measurement? - Part 2
Do you think you know OA control? Separate min OA volume measurement? - Part 2

Outside air volume measurement helps, but it does not solve all our control issues.

Do you think you know OA control? IAQ Control? RAF tracking - Part 1
Do you think you know OA control? IAQ Control? RAF tracking - Part 1

There are millions of buildings around the world that have the incorrect outside air being drawn in from the AHUs.

Our BMS graphics suck - part 2
Our BMS graphics suck - part 2

If you don’t have these graphics, then you are not optimising the BMS.

Our BMS graphics suck - part 1
Our BMS graphics suck - part 1

Graphics are the easiest thing to enhance to impress our customers. But, we continue to deliver the most simple graphics.

Simple PID adjustment that saves energy
Simple PID adjustment that saves energy

When we want to save energy, we often start with the major systems. E.g., the chilled water system. But, there are a lot of small changes that can be made, which can often be done during BMS service time.

Why your company can't pay for advanced training
Why your company can't pay for advanced training

BMS companies are not training their engineers and managers in advanced concepts. If they are not going to do it, then you should consider investing in your own career.

Issues with multi-vendor BMS systems Part 3
Issues with multi-vendor BMS systems Part 3

Like everything, there are pros and cons that need to be considered when you have a multi-vendor BMS.

Multi-vendor BMS systems – where is the lock in? Part 2
Multi-vendor BMS systems – where is the lock in? Part 2

Even if you have a multi-vendor BMS system, you can easily still get locked-in.

Open system vs open protocol – where is the lock in? Part 1
Open system vs open protocol – where is the lock in? Part 1

The definition of an open system changes depending on who you ask.

How many devices can you put on an RS485 Sub-network?
How many devices can you put on an RS485 Sub-network?

We have been following the same rule for over 30 years. Is it time to reconsider how we look at our serial sub-network designs?

Where did all the BMS people go?
Where did all the BMS people go?

They were here, and now they are not. I thought I’d sit down and try to work this one out as no one has given me a good answer yet.

How to submit a good quality BMS technical submission
How to submit a good quality BMS technical submission

There are a few basics that I feel have gotten lost over the years. If you are a BMS engineer and you submit BMS technical submissions for review, then you should watch this video.

Support for Windows Server 2012 will END October, 2023
Support for Windows Server 2012 will END October, 2023

If you have any Windows Server 2012 operating systems, then you need to get fee proposals in right now so that the funding will be available next year.

What are we going to give away next?
What are we going to give away next?

10 years ago, we gave away Energy Management Systems, 5 years ago we gave away building analytics. What are we going to give away next?

BMS Net Zero - Measurement and Verification
BMS Net Zero - Measurement and Verification

The BMS Net Zero program. Know exactly how you are going to test your optimisation efforts and how you are going to prove the reduced power consumption before you start. If you can not prove the saving, then there is no saving!

BMS Net Zero - Where to Start
BMS Net Zero - Where to Start

The BMS Net Zero program. Which systems you start optimising is important. If you do not start with the right system, you may need to come back later and do it again.

BMS Net Zero - Introduction
BMS Net Zero - Introduction

We do not need millions of electric cars, millions of wind turbines, millions of solar panels, billions of dollars - we just need time to update the software programs in millions of existing BMS controllers. And, we can do this during normal service time. We already have a maintenance contract, we are already getting paid to go to site. Why not update the code while we are there?

I'll Bet Your VAV AHU Dirty Filter Monitoring is WRONG. You Will be Surprised
I'll Bet Your VAV AHU Dirty Filter Monitoring is WRONG. You Will be Surprised

A differential pressure switch, used to determine if a filter is dirty, does not really work on VAV AHU's. This is another one of those things, where something changed 20 years ago, and we did not realise that our monitoring system needed to change.

What are we going to GIVE AWAY next?
What are we going to GIVE AWAY next?

Five years ago we gave away building Analytics, ten years ago we gave away Energy Management Systems. What are we going to give away in the next five years?

When will AI / ML Become Useful in Buildings? 5 years? 10 Years?
When will AI / ML Become Useful in Buildings? 5 years? 10 Years?

In this video we discuss the concept of just what may be possible if we all work together.

Covid is causing Outside Air Control Issues
Covid is causing Outside Air Control Issues

After thought: When the health department talks about buildings that do not have enough outside air, they are probably talking about hotels, age care living, apartments, C-Grade buildings with DX air conditioning. I don't think this lack of outside air applies to premium grade and A-Grade buildings in expensive cities around the world, built in the past 10 years. They are often designed with lots of outside air (above code requirements).

System Pressure Control (Part 3)
System Pressure Control (Part 3)

This is the final video in a 3 part series on the design of the system pressure transmitter.

System Pressure Control (Part 2)
System Pressure Control (Part 2)

This is the 2nd video in a 3 part series on the design of the system pressure transmitter. In part 2 we look at three things to consider if the transmitter is installed far away from the chiller plant room.

Bryce Anderson
Previous

How Important is it to YOU that Your Projects make Money?
Next

Are we permitted to Interlock the Car Park Ventilation System with a Time Schedule?